As an NRI returning to India with investments in a 529 savings plan, understanding Indian tax law implications is important. Parents living in the United States invest in 529 savings plans for their children's education, which is a smart move if you are in the USA.
Upon returning to indian, the taxation scenario will change entirely. The 529 savings plan, which is known for its tax-free growth and withdrawals in the US, becomes taxable under the Indian tax laws.
Hence, it is important to understand how the Indian tax system will affect your 529 accounts.
In this blog, we will talk about 529 Plan Indian tax implications, what will happen when your child studies outside India, and whether or not a more flexible option exists.
Key Takeaways
- 529 plans are US tax-saving accounts used to pay for educational expenses, such as apprenticeship programs, credentialing programs, student loan repayment, K-12 education, and more.
- 529 plans grow on a tax-deferred basis in the US, but when the NRI returns to India and attains ROR status, the growth becomes taxable under Indian tax law. As per the law, the global income of an ROR (Resident and Ordinarily Resident) is taxable in India.
- Other than the 529 plan for NRIs, a better alternative for NRIs returning to India is a Traditional IRA.
What is Plan 529, and Why Do NRIs Use It?
The 529 Plan is a tax-saving investment option governed by the US Internal Revenue Code. This plan allows the money invested in it to grow on a tax-deferred basis. It can be withdrawn tax-free only for qualified expenses, such as college fees, K-12 tuition, apprenticeship programs, student loan payments, credentialing programs, and so on.
Although anyone can open a 529 account, it is often opened by grandparents or parents to save for their grandchild's or child's future educational costs, especially for U.S.-born children of Non-resident Indians (NRIs).
Another reason for NRIs to choose plan 529 is:
- There is no federal tax imposed on investment gains if used for qualified education.
- The plan is also exempt from estate taxes if it is structured properly (via 5-year superannuation).
- Control of the 529 accounts remains with the account holder, even as the child grows up.
- But upon moving back to India, this is where the trouble for NRIs begins.
On moving back to India and becoming a tax resident there, the core advantage of a 529 plan account — its tax-free growth — diminishes, and the Indian tax department treats the account differently.
Why Most Asian Universities Do Not Qualify For 529 Plan Withdrawals.
529 plans allow funding for higher education, but in reality, the list of eligible universities that accept 529 funds is limited. As per the IRS, the list of eligible institutions in Asia includes only a few Singaporean universities.
Other eligible international universities and colleges are based in Australia and Europe. Universities in India do not qualify for the 529 plan funding. So if your child decides to study in India or elsewhere in Asia (excluding the selected institutions in Singapore), your withdrawals will not qualify under Internal Revenue Service rules.
Here is a key impact. Non-qualified withdrawals are subject to income tax on earnings and an additional 10% penalty under US Tax law. And this penalty passes out the tax benefits 529s offer.
How Does the 529 Plan Income Get Taxes When NRIs Become Tax Residents In India?
Upon returning to India and attaining Resident and Prinarily Resident (ROR) status, the Indian Government taxes your global income, including income earned in the 529 plan.
As US tax laws allow 529 growth to be tax-deferred, but Indian laws do not, any growth will be subject to taxes under Indian law. This growth can be in the form of interest, dividends, capital gains, and more.
Now, this creates double trouble for NRIs after attaining the status of ROR, that is:
Since your global income will be taxed as ROR, the tax deferral on 529 plan growth will not apply, and there will be no exemption or postponement of tax on 529 plan growth.
Secondly, as per Section 89A of the Income Tax Act, the deferral in foreign retirement accounts is allowed, but Plan 529 does not qualify as one.
A Smart Alternative For Education Savings - Traditional IRA For US Education
As a parent, if you are not sure your child will return to the US or another eligible university for higher education abroad, then a Traditional IRA is a more flexible option.
It is because any earnings in a Traditional IRA for higher education are exempt from the 10% penalty on early distributions, yes, even if you are under 59 and a half.
Although IRA contributions have income limits and the growth benefits are not as lucrative as those of 529 plans, a Traditional IRA still offers you.
- More flexibility in using it.
- US education penalty-free access
- No taxation is imposed on traditional IRAs until withdrawal. Upon withdrawal, the amount is taxed as ordinary income.
A Quick Comparison - 529 Plan Vs Traditional IRA for NRIs Returning to India
| Feature |
The 529 Plan |
Traditional IRA |
| Tax Free in the United States |
Yes, but if you are qualified |
Yes, but if you are qualified. |
| Indian Tax Post-Return |
Taxed Annually after ROR |
Taxed on withdrawals only. |
| Eligible Institutions Abroad |
Very limited, mainly in Singapore, Australia, and Europe. |
Not tied to any of the institutions. |
| Early Withdrawal Penalty |
10% for the non-qualified |
No penalty for education expenses |
| Estate Planning Benefit |
Yes (Superfunding) |
No |
The Bottom Line
As an NRI, having a 529 plan is a great move, but before investing in it, ask yourself: Are you 100% sure that your child will study in the United States or at an IRS-recognized institution?
The second question you will ask yourself is whether you are comfortable paying taxes in India annually on the income from your 529 accounts after your return to India.
And the last question you will ask yourself is whether or not you are using the plan mainly for estate tax planning in the United States.
Now, if the answer to any one of the questions is NO, please consider alternatives like a Traditional IRA or broader investing options in the United States that offer similar flexibility and a lower tax rate once you retire to India.
As a returning NRI, if you need personalized expert-backed advice on US investments after returning to India, connect with Savetaxs. For a decade and more, we have been helping NRIs manage their:
- Cross-border investments, NRI taxation planning.
- US 529 plans, IRA, and brokerage account taxation compliance in India.
- Annual tax filing in India under the ROR statutes, and our experts will also consult you on double taxation or relief.
Connect with us for one-to-one consultations with the top CAs and CPAs in the world of NRI taxation.
*Note: This guide is for informational purposes only. The views expressed in this guide are personal and do not constitute the views of Savetaxs. Savetaxs or the author will not be responsible for any direct or indirect loss incurred by the reader for taking any decision based on the information or the contents. It is advisable to consult either a CA, CS, CPA, or a professional tax expert from the Savetaxs team, as they are familiar with the current regulations and help you make accurate decisions and maintain accuracy throughout the whole process.
India
USA
Tax Consultancy Services
_1753429421.webp "A Guide on the Types of TDS (Tax Deducted at Source) in India")
(i)-Of-The-Income-Tax-Act_1756812791.webp "All About Section 40(a)(i) Of The Income Tax Act")
-plan_1761282887.webp "All You Need to Know About 401(k) Plan")
_1754392689.webp "Income Tax Act Section 148: Assessment or Reassessment")
